Nov 2 · Remi · I filed Remi's trademark applications with IMPI, Mexico's trademark office. ›
← Blog

Donna: 700K users and it never made money

Donna, formerly WeHelp, was a personal safety app that reached 700K registered users and #1 on the App Store, and it never became a profitable business. It started in 2019 as WeHelp, added physical security and a call center in 2022, and in 2023 became Donna, an app just for women. It no longer operates.

Carlos Gotlib5 min read
A woman walks at night down a street in Mexico City holding her phone, next to the text 700K users and it never made money
In short
  • WeHelp hit #1 among free apps on the App Store in January 2019 and grew to 700K registered users.
  • Most of the people using it were women, so in 2023 we focused only on them and renamed it Donna.
  • It didn't work as a business: people valued safety, but weren't willing to pay enough to make the numbers work.

Donna, formerly WeHelp, was my personal safety app. It hit #1 among free apps on the App Store in January 2019, grew to 700K registered users, and never made money. People loved it and used it, but we couldn't cover what it cost to run. It no longer operates.

This is the full story: where it came from, the post that made it go viral, why it became an app for women, and why it died.

The idea came to me in the shower

I was showering and asked myself: if I'm in a bank, someone walks in with a gun, and I can't call 911, how do I get help?

That's how WeHelp started: a button that, when you press it, alerts your emergency contacts.

Then we added the feature that made it different. The alert also went to other users registered as helpers, the "heroes," who were within a kilometer of you.

Bastian's post

That second feature is what made it blow up.

On January 28, 2019, a user named Bastian Ramírez posted on Facebook about what happened to him. He'd installed the app out of curiosity. His phone went off with an alert near his house, he ran to the location, and saw a young woman walking scared with a man behind her. He showed her the app, took her by the arm, and the man changed direction. Outlets like BioBioChile told the story in his own words.

That post now has 79.2K reactions and 125K shares. We were in every outlet and got hundreds of thousands of downloads. WeHelp hit #1 among free apps on the App Store.

It wasn't the first time this had happened to me: in 2015 I'd done it with SpeakOn.

Screenshot of Bastian Ramírez's January 28, 2019 Facebook post about the WeHelp app, with 79.2K reactions and 125K shares

Screenshot of Bastian Ramírez's January 28, 2019 post about WeHelp. It shows 79.2K reactions and 125K shares; it is not a photograph of the event he describes.

Why did it become an app for women?

Because the data said so. We saw that the people using it most were women: to go out alone at night, to get into an Uber or a taxi, to go on a date.

So we built a version designed for them: Donna.

What did Donna do?

Donna wasn't just a button anymore. It was a service with people behind it:

  • 24/7 call center that called 911 for you.
  • Help if you got lost in a dangerous area.
  • Map of safe places: purple points, police, ambulances, fire stations, and nearby hospitals.
  • Trip monitoring from point A to point B, with agents following along.
  • Arrival-home detector: if you didn't make it home, we'd check if you were okay.

We hired a woman who made videos of use cases: getting into a taxi, riding the metro. Several "Somos Donna" videos on TikTok and Instagram reached millions of views.

Timeline

| Stage | What happened |
|---|---|
| WeHelp | SOS button that alerts your contacts and helpers within a kilometer. |
| January 28, 2019 | Bastian's post goes viral; #1 among free apps on the App Store. |
| Growth | Hundreds of thousands of downloads; 700K registered users. |
| Donna | Version for women with a 24/7 call center and trip monitoring. |
| Shutdown | We couldn't keep the call center going. |

How did we try to make money?

With plans from 99 to 149 pesos a month.

The answer we heard most was some version of "the government should be providing safety." People wanted the service, but felt it wasn't on them to pay for it.

And what made Donna valuable was exactly the most expensive part. The button is cheap to run. A 24/7 call center isn't. We couldn't sustain it, and that's why Donna died.

I go deeper on this in Why people don't pay for safety apps.

What worked

  • We built something people wanted. We didn't pay for Bastian's post; a user wrote it.
  • We read correctly who cared most. The switch to Donna came from looking at who was using it.
  • Real stories connected. The "Somos Donna" videos showed a taxi or the metro, not features, and several reached millions of views.

What I'd do differently

  1. Validate who pays before growing. We grew for free first and looked for the model later.
  2. Don't set up a 24/7 call center without a proven price. It's a fixed cost that keeps running even if nobody presses the button.
  3. Look for a third party to pay from day one. Employers, insurers, or transportation companies have business reasons to keep people safe. That's what I'd explore today.

Five questions before launching a safety app

  1. Who pays? The user, her employer, an insurer. By name, not in general.
  2. How much do they pay, with real money? Not what they say in a survey.
  3. Which part of the service needs people? Every person awake at 3 a.m. is a fixed cost.
  4. What happens in a real emergency? If the answer ends up being call 911, be honest about what the app actually solves.
  5. How often is it used? Something you hope you never use is hard to charge for every month.

What I took away

People using something doesn't mean they'll pay for it. Users aren't a business.

Today, before building, the first question I ask is who pulls out the card, how much they pay, and whether that covers the cost of delivering the service. That question weighed on me in every round of From 112 ideas to 7. The story of all my companies is in who I am and why I now build in public.

Frequently asked questions

What is the Donna app?

Donna was a personal safety app for women in Latin America, founded by Carlos Gotlib. It used to be called WeHelp.

What was WeHelp?

The original version of Donna, launched in 2019 for anyone. In 2023 it refocused on women only and changed its name to Donna.

How did Donna work?

With an SOS button that alerted your contacts and a call center, trips monitored by agents, and the option to ask nearby users for help.

How many users did Donna have?

700K registered users. As WeHelp, it hit #1 among free apps on the App Store in January 2019.

Is Donna still running?

No. It shut down because it never found a profitable business model.

Learn how to build a company by watching me build mine.

Every week: the decision, the number, the mistake and the win.