Why people won't pay for safety apps
People won't pay for safety apps because they feel safety is the government's job, not theirs. I learned this with Donna, formerly WeHelp: 700,000 registered users, #1 on the App Store, and never a profitable business. Everyone wanted the app; almost no one wanted to pay what it cost to run.

- Just because a problem is urgent doesn't mean anyone will pay for it out of pocket.
- A service with people behind it, like a 24/7 call center, has fixed costs that a low price can't cover.
- If no one pays directly, you have to find who will: a company, an insurer, or an employer.
The short answer: people do want a safety app, but almost no one wants to pay for it. They feel their safety is the government's responsibility, and an app can't send a police car. I lived this with Donna, formerly WeHelp: 700,000 registered users, #1 on the App Store, and never a profitable business.
Every so often someone tells me they're going to launch a safety app. They're almost always right that the problem is huge. Where they go wrong, like I did, is believing that's enough to build a business.
Is there real demand for safety apps in Mexico?
Yes, a lot. The fear is real, and it's measured.
In September 2026, 58.1% of adults living in Mexican cities said living in their city is unsafe, according to INEGI's National Survey of Urban Public Safety (ENSU). Among women it was 64.2%; among men, 50.6%. The same survey says 61.8% feel unsafe on the street and 61.1% on public transportation.
I saw it firsthand. The idea for WeHelp came to me in the shower: if I'm in a bank, someone armed walks in, and I can't call 911, how do I ask for help? We built a button that alerted your emergency contacts and other users registered as helpers within a kilometer or less.
On January 28, 2019, a user named Bastian Ramírez shared on Facebook how an alert from the app led him to help a young woman who was being followed by a man. That post now has 79.2K reactions and 125K shares. We were all over the media, hundreds of thousands of downloads came in, and the app hit #1 among free apps on the App Store. Over time it reached 700,000 registered users.
We saw that the people using it most were women: to go out alone at night, take an Uber or a taxi, go on a date. That's why we built Donna, a version designed for them.
Demand was never the problem. The problem was who pays.

Screenshot of Bastian Ramírez's January 28, 2019 post about WeHelp. It shows 79.2K reactions and 125K shares; it is not a photograph of the event he describes.
Why won't people pay for a safety app?
I'd sum it up in four reasons. I saw the first three directly with our users; the fourth I understood later, from the numbers.
1. Safety feels like a right, not a product
When we asked people if they'd pay, the most common answer was some version of "the government should provide safety." And it makes sense. You already pay taxes. Paying extra to feel safe feels like paying twice for the same thing.
A music or streaming app sells something you want. A safety app sells something you feel you're already owed.
2. The app doesn't solve the whole problem
Donna did a lot: a 24/7 call center that called 911 for you, help if you were lost in a dangerous area, a map with purple points, nearby police, ambulances, fire stations, and hospitals, agents who monitored your trip from A to B, and an arrived-home detector. But it didn't have its own police to send to the scene. In a real emergency, the last piece was still 911.
For someone who already feels safety is the government's job, paying for an app that ends up calling 911 is hard to justify.
3. People pay for what they use often, not for what they hope they'll never use
A panic button is like a fire extinguisher: you want to have it, but you hope you never use it. That's good for the user's life and bad for a monthly subscription. Every month nothing happens, the question is the same: what am I paying for?
4. The price people accept doesn't cover the service
We had plans from 99 to 149 pesos a month. Some people would pay, but not much. And what makes a safety app truly worth something is expensive: people.
In 2022 we added physical security and a call center with agents who monitored trips. That changes the whole model. A service with people awake 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, has fixed costs that exist even if no one presses the button that night. The price people were willing to pay never covered them. We couldn't sustain the call center, and that's why Donna died.
The trap of the free app that goes viral
This is the mistake that took me longest to see.
A free app that grows fast feels like success. You have downloads, press, and messages from people thanking you. Everything says you're doing well.
But downloads measure interest, not willingness to pay. With WeHelp we grew first and thought about the model later. By the time we added what actually costs money, the call center and physical security, we already had hundreds of thousands of users used to paying nothing.
Something similar had already happened to me with SpeakOn, my app that hit #1 on the App Store: reaching first place doesn't tell you whether there's a business behind it.
The full story of the app is in Donna: 700,000 users and it never made money.
So, how do you monetize a safety app?
I don't have a proven formula, because I didn't find one. But I do know what I'd explore today, in this order:
- Find someone to pay instead of the user. Employers who want to look after their people when they travel or leave late, insurers, or transportation companies. For them, a person's safety has a value they can measure.
- Separate what's free from what costs money. The SOS button and alerting your contacts can be free forever. Monitoring with human agents can't.
- Charge per moment, not per month. If people use the service at specific moments, like a trip at night, it may make more sense to charge for that moment than for a subscription that feels empty.
- Test the price before scaling. Know how much people really pay, with real money, before building a 24/7 call center.
What I'd do differently
If I started WeHelp again, I'd do three things differently from day one.
- I'd ask who pays before writing a single line of code. Not "whether people would like it," but who pulls out their card, and how much.
- I wouldn't add people to the service without a validated price. A call center is a fixed cost. It only makes sense once you know someone is going to cover it.
- I'd measure revenue per user from the start, not just downloads. Downloads made me feel we were doing well for far too long.
These lessons are part of how I choose what to work on today. I write about it in who I am and why I now build in public and in what 32 startup investments taught me.
Frequently asked questions
Why do safety apps fail?
Because many people feel their safety is the government's responsibility, and because an app doesn't solve the whole problem: in a real emergency, it ends up alerting your contacts or calling 911. That's why few people pay enough to cover a service with people behind it, like a 24/7 call center.
How do you monetize a personal safety app?
Direct payment from the user is rarely enough. The alternatives I'd explore are having a third party pay, like an employer, an insurer, or a transportation company, and keeping the SOS button free while charging only for services that involve people, like trip monitoring.
Why did the Donna app shut down?
Because the numbers never worked: with 700,000 registered users, what people were willing to pay never covered the cost of running the service, especially the call center and physical security.
Can a viral app fail as a business?
Yes. Donna, formerly WeHelp, went viral several times and hit #1 among free apps on the App Store in January 2019, and it was still never profitable. Downloads measure interest, not willingness to pay.
Is there demand for safety apps in Mexico?
Yes. According to INEGI's ENSU survey, in September 2026, 58.1% of adults in Mexican cities said living in their city is unsafe, and among women it was 64.2%. The demand is there; the hard part is getting someone to pay for the service.
Learn how to build a company by watching me build mine.
Every week: the decision, the number, the mistake and the win.