Nov 2 · Remi · I filed Remi's trademark applications with IMPI, Mexico's trademark office. ›
← Blog

32 startup investments: what the 14 that shut down taught me

Since 2016 I've invested in 32 startups, 27 of them backed by Y Combinator. Today 17 are still alive, one had an exit, and 14 shut down. Almost half didn't make it, and none has had a big exit yet. This is what angel investing really looks like.

Carlos Gotlib5 min read
Carlos Gotlib in an olive green overshirt with arms crossed next to the text 14 of 32 shut down
In short
  • I started investing after Y Combinator turned down SpeakOn, my first startup, for lack of "technical skills."
  • I write checks of around 25 thousand dollars per company.
  • The only exit, Plerk, was paid in shares of the acquiring company, not in cash.

Since 2016 I've invested in 32 startups, 27 of them backed by Y Combinator. Today 17 are still alive, one had an exit, and 14 shut down. Almost half didn't make it, and none has had a big exit yet. This is what angel investing really looks like.

I'm writing this because almost everything published about investing in startups talks about the wins. Here are my full numbers, including the ones that died, and what I learned from them.

How did I start investing in startups?

I applied to Y Combinator with SpeakOn, my first startup. We made it to the first interview and weren't accepted because the team lacked "technical skills."

I didn't get in as a founder, but I stayed close to the YC community. In 2016 I started investing in startups, and I've made 32 investments since. 27 of those companies went through Y Combinator.

The SpeakOn story is in SpeakOn: the app that hit #1 on the App Store in Mexico and why it died.

How do I invest?

| Criteria | How I do it |
|---|---|
| Check size | Around 25 thousand dollars per company |
| Stage | Mostly seed rounds, the riskiest ones |
| How I find companies | I do the searching: I review the ones that get into each YC batch |
| Focus | Latin American founders |
| Exception | Airthium, which I got into through a syndicate |

I do the searching. That's how I found Plerk, Writesonic, and almost all of them: through YC. I reviewed the startups accepted into each batch, picked the ones I liked, reached out to the founders, almost always on LinkedIn, and got into their rounds. Nobody introduced me. With Writesonic, the first message was on Instagram.

Why I invest. I like helping other founders because I know what it's like to be there. I know how hard it is to get into YC from Mexico, and when a team from here gets in, I want to back them. I also know it's very risky: I come in at seed, where the most companies fall by the wayside.

How does the portfolio look today?

Out of 32 startups:

| Status | Number |
|---|---|
| Still active | 17 |
| Shut down | 14 |
| Had an exit | 1 |

Among the active ones, some of the best performers are Tovala, Writesonic, Filadd, Fitia, Cero, and Nectome. Among the ones that shut down: Kanda, Wayru Network, Skylights, Saphibeat, Nestdrop, Moonshot Brands, and Kodda.

The full portfolio is in Investments.

What do the numbers show?

Almost half shut down. 14 of 32. That's 44%.

The YC ones shut down less. Of the 27 Y Combinator companies, 9 shut down, one in three. All 5 that didn't come from YC shut down.

Five companies isn't a big enough sample to make a rule. But in my case, the difference is clear.

Ten years and no big exit. I started in 2016. The ones still alive are still building, and the only exit I've had wasn't in cash.

This is what almost nobody tells you: angel investing is slow. You can go a decade without seeing a single dollar back, even if your portfolio is doing well.

What did the 14 that shut down teach me?

Investing in startups is high risk. Most fail.

None of the ones that shut down hurt. I see it as part of the business: I go in at seed knowing many won't make it.

Looking back at the ones that died helps me see patterns. The clearest one: almost all the ones that shut down weren't solving a real problem.

Put another way: they solved something that didn't hurt people enough to change what they were already doing, or to pay.

With Plerk, what made me say yes was the problem they were solving. Same with Writesonic. Today that's the first question I ask about any investment, and about my own companies too: does this hurt someone today?

I learned it as a founder too. Donna reached 700 thousand users and never made money. Sometimes the problem is real, but nobody is willing to pay to solve it.

Is an exit always a check?

No. My only exit proves it.

Plerk is an employee benefits startup from Guadalajara. It got into Y Combinator in 2020, and that's when I invested.

In 2023 it merged with minu, and my Plerk shares were swapped for minu shares. I didn't get any money. It counts as an exit because Plerk no longer exists on its own, but my money is still invested, now in minu.

When people hear "exit," they think of a check. In early-stage investing, the acquiring company often pays with its own shares. The full story is in Plerk and minu: why I invested in Plerk and what happened with the merger.

If you want to start investing in startups

What I'd tell someone thinking about their first angel investment, based on what these 32 taught me:

  1. Only invest what you can afford to lose completely. Almost half of my investments are worth zero.
  2. Think in decades, not years. In ten years I haven't had a big exit.
  3. Do your own searching. You don't need an introduction. Review the batches, write directly to the founders, and say why you're interested.
  4. Start with the problem. Before the product, the market, or the team, ask whether it hurts someone today.
  5. Understand what an exit is. It can be in shares, not cash.

Why am I not investing in startups today?

Because right now I want to invest in myself. I'm not looking for new investments.

My time and money are going into building, and I talk about it in what Carlos Gotlib does.

What I took away

Investing in 32 startups gave me something I didn't expect: seeing from the outside how other founders win and lose. That's half of my judgment when I build.

And it left me with a simple rule: if the problem isn't real, nothing else matters.

Frequently asked questions

How many startups has Carlos Gotlib invested in?

32 since 2016, 27 of them from Y Combinator. 17 are still active, one had an exit (Plerk), and 14 shut down.

How much does Carlos Gotlib invest per startup?

Around 25 thousand dollars per company, at an early stage.

How many Y Combinator startups fail?

In Carlos Gotlib's portfolio, 9 of 27 YC companies shut down. All 5 non-YC companies shut down.

What happened with Plerk?

Plerk was acquired by minu, a Mexican company, and investors received minu shares instead of cash.

How do you start investing in Y Combinator startups?

For Carlos Gotlib, it all happened through YC: he reviewed the startups accepted into each batch, reached out to the founders, almost always on LinkedIn, and got into their seed rounds.

Is Carlos Gotlib investing today?

No. He isn't looking for new investments right now because he wants to invest in himself.

Learn how to build a company by watching me build mine.

Every week: the decision, the number, the mistake and the win.